We've all done it – grabbed a bundle for one game and ignored the other ten. Or downloaded a free Game Pass title without knowing anything about it. The truth is, your backlog probably has some absolute bangers hiding in there, just waiting for you to give them a shot. The trick is figuring out which ones deserve your time.
What actually makes a hidden gem
A hidden gem isn't just a good game nobody played. It's usually an indie or mid-tier game that didn't get much marketing, but delivers an experience that punches way above its budget. Think Hades before everyone knew about it, or Outer Wilds before the word-of-mouth explosion. These games have small but passionate communities for a reason.
How to spot the good stuff in your pile
Instead of scrolling endlessly, try these approaches to find games worth playing:
- Look for high user scores with decent review counts – if 2,000 people gave it 9/10, they're onto something
- Give weird-looking indie games a chance – some of the best gaming experiences come from the oddest premises
- Check time to beat stats – sometimes a tight 6-hour experience beats a bloated 40-hour one
- Ask around in gaming communities – Reddit and Discord folks love recommending underrated games
Stop sleeping on great games
The biggest waste isn't having unplayed games – it's ignoring the amazing ones because they didn't have a Super Bowl ad. Next time you're wondering what to play, look past the obvious AAA choices. That quirky game you barely remember adding? Give it an hour. You might just find your new favorite game was sitting in your library all along.
Ready to organize your gaming backlog?
Start using Play Wisp to track, organize, and prioritize your games.
Get started free